The Simmons Review- V.4

Wednesday, August 09, 2006

Wow! Two in one day!!! Aren't you special? Here's the next one on our list. We get bypassed by the Vegas article again for yet another Sports Guy's Rules/Changes/Countdowns, but here's the CRAZY thing......I actually liked it!

At this point the ESPN the Mag articles are the only thing of his that is readable from start to finish. I swear that ESPN pays him by the word for those mailbags. Let's get into this thing with a few comments as we go.

4) David Stern resigns … but to become President of the United States.
Agreed. I can't think of another person that has turned a business around like that. Think of what he could do with a country.

5) The Knicks extend Isiah's deal through 2015 by explaining, "This had nothing to do with winning or losing. We had to do it for comedy's sake."
Everyone agrees on this I think.

6) Julio Franco isn't allowed to retire. He has to keep playing until we all agree he can stop. Let's see how far this can go.
As does everyone on this point as well.

7) All right, would you rather keep reading boring story after boring story about the messy ownership situations with the Sonics and Hawks … or would you rather see them merge franchises, move to Vegas and immediately become the Las Vegas Dice? (Wow, you picked the latter! I can't believe it!)
Not bad....not a bad idea at all.

8) Sideline reporters -- gone. We survived the World Cup without them, right?
Oh you knew I was agreeing with this right away.

9) I'm not ready to abolish baseball's All-Star Game, even though the voting process sucks, every writer/radio host tries to pretend it's a national tragedy that so-and-so didn't make it (even though nobody can remember who played two weeks later), and the crowd always lapses into a collective coma by the third inning. But instead of "starting lineups," let's vote on "finishing lineups" -- the eight best position players come in for the sixth and play the rest of the game. Shouldn't the elite stars decide homefield advantage for the World Series? Besides, we need another format for A-Rod to choke in the clutch.
Not sure about this idea, but after this year's game....anything could help.

10) No more long putters, no more DH, no more puff pieces, no more sportswriters screaming at each other on TV, no more pickoff throws (you can only take a lead to a certain point), no more canned music during NBA play, no more Barbaro coverage.
The lead thing is just dumb, but everything else I agree with.

11) We all agree that A) there will never be another MJ, and B) we're not allowed to compare anyone to him.
Agreed.

12) Men's tennis switches to a best-of-seven format with shorter sets -- first to four wins a set, and if there's a 4-4 tie, then we go to a longer tiebreaker (first to 10 points). I want to care about tennis again. Really, I do.
This is one of the only ones I have a problem with. Men's tennis just will never be good in the United States. I think Soccer only survives because kids play it religiously when they are younger and never truly grow out of it. Tennis I just cannot get into....well Men's Tennis.

13) The Olympics and the World Cup happen every three years, not four. You can never have too much of a good thing.
I agree with the WC, but not the Olympics. NBC's coverage is nauseating, and with it every three years the network would go under.

14) Mike Shanahan agrees to stop platooning running backs and messing with the minds of countless fantasy owners.
I'm begining to think he might actually read this site. Are you Anonymous Bill?

15) No more NIT. Come on, you can't have a tournament to determine the 65th best player in any sport. Imagine if there was a Junior Emmys to determine the 65th best TV actress, TV actor, sitcom, drama … would that ever happen?
This I cannot agree with because Maryland wouldn't have anywhere to play come March. Actually yes, let's get rid of it.

16) The Patriots go back to blood-red uniforms and the Pat Patriot logo. Enough is enough. I want my childhood back.
Those Unis were badass. Too bad the team wasn't.

17) Baseball adopts the relegation system from the English Premier league -- lose 100 games or more and you're shipped to Triple-A for one season. That means you, Kansas City.
I can go along with that.

18) In the NBA, you can't call a timeout immediately after another timeout, you can't call time in midair and you can't call time trailing by more than six with less than 20 seconds to play.
I extremely agree. I'm a degenerate and I've lost too many bets that way.

19) Fans get to vote on entrance music for their closers. If Detroit fans want to saddle Todd Jones with Tom Petty's "Stop Dragging My Heart Around" or Nirvana's "Rape Me," that's their choice. Also, all teams are required to use the bullpen car again. I miss the bullpen car.
Not sure about this one. The bullpen car is always a winner.

20) Boxing takes a cue from the UFC and WWE and shifts to one monster pay-per-view every month (three hours of quality fights and a main event). Also, they go from three judges to five. And Don King is deported.
Couldn't agree more. I watched Forrest v. Quartey this past Saturday and the judging was awful. Quartey won by at least 5 rounds and ended up losing by two. Forrest even had a point taken away for low blows! Boxing is so fixed right now.

21) No more aluminum bats in college. We're reaching the point where some roid-enhanced line drive is going to rip through a pitcher's head like an assassin's bullet.
Didn't a few people die already?

22) Whenever there's a replay challenge or serious injury in the NFL, they have to immediately go to a commercial, bang out as many ads as possible, then come back and tell us what happened. We could wipe out 10 minutes of TV timeouts per game.
Agreed.

23 When two NASCAR drivers get into a post-race fight, it has to be like hockey -- everyone else stands back and lets the two guys have it out, even if they end up pulling their fire retardant suits over each other's heads.
There is nothing more wimpy than a NASCAR fight. I'm sorry Jeffmina Gordon does not intimidate me.

24) Speaking of hockey, the NHL has to dump six teams, cut down to a 70-game season and make every playoff series a best-of-nine. Also, they can't show their playoff games on any network that could potentially give them a 2002 "Survivor" re-run as a lead-in.
Another one I don't agree with. There's no way I could last through a nine game series.

25) To spruce up the always-lame PGA Championship, every player has to go caddy-less and carry his own bags for 72 holes. Now that's a major! Like you wouldn't watch just to see who was fading by Day Three, or to see Mickelson fighting off tears and saying things like, "This is a wakeup call, maybe I need to cut down on the carbs" after shooting a 92 and throwing up on the 14th hole.
The Mickelson visual made me laugh-out-loud.

26) Cameras are no longer allowed to zoom in within 18 inches of somebody's face. I don't need any more unpopped whiteheads, acne scars and dangling nose hairs in my life.
Agreed.

27) My bosses won't allow me to say which six announcers I would deport to Eastern Europe, but here are their initials jumbled together backwards: WBMABCMJMTBJ.
Thanks to some Deadspinners your answers are Joe Buck, Tim McCarver, Joe Morgan, Chris Berman, Al Michaels, Bill Walton. I agree on everyone but Bill Walton.....I think I like him now. He doesn't know what he's saying half the time, but he truly loves the game....unlike some of the other pompous asses on that list.

28) For the "Season Pass" packages on DirecTV, we'd always have the option of watching the telecast with our favorite team's announcers. What's the point of shelling out two bills a year for the NBA or baseball and not getting your own guys every game? And while we're on the subject, no more blacking out Saturday's early Fox games on the West Coast. Unless you want me to eventually kill someone.

29) For NBA All-Star Weekend: A H-O-R-S-E contest, a halfcourt shot contest and a dunk contest with a rim that keeps raising like a high jump bar. I keep pushing for these three things, they keep ignoring me.
I'm down with HORSE and the halfcourt, but the high jump bar would get boring.

30) Sunglasses are banned from professional poker, for two reasons: A) it's more interesting to see everyone's eyes, and B) it's hard to defend any sport where the players dress up like blind tourists.
Poker isn't a sport so I refuse to comment.

31) At least one NHL team would be required to attempt the 500-pound goalie thing. Even if it's for an exhibition game.

32) If someone has front row seats and brings their small child with them, and that poor kid subsequently gets struck by a foul ball or accidentally trampled by a gigantic basketball player … then the parent loses all parental rights to that kid and Shea Hillenbrand gets to adopt him or her.
I chuckled at this one....Shea would be a great surrogate.

33) Barry Bonds goes to jail. We needed to mention that one twice.
I'm an innocent before proven guilty guy, but come on.....this has to happen.

So there you have it. I can go from one extreme to the other in a matter of minutes. I'm not all that bad am I? Here's the judging:

Timing and Relevance: Doesn't really pertain to this article. I think the majority of the ideas were fresh ones (minus the 500lb goalie and the NBA All-Star game stuff).

Number of Boston Sports References: Only one mention....not bad. The forum didn't really allow for many though.

Knowledge and Conveyance of Knowledge: This was an A+ in my mind. It's not just the recent rambling and make a bad joke of late. These were well thought out ideas, and some very plausible.

Overall Writing and Impact: I thought this was a great piece of sports writing. It wasn't overly pretentious or egotistical, and it got the point across.

Grade: I'm giving this one a 4 out of 5 Boston Championship Rings. It was a borderline 4.5, and is probably a 4.25, but I'm not photoshopping another ring. I think I was overly harsh in V.3, but I'm getting bitter here folks. Maybe, just maybe, he threw me a bone here.....nah probably not. I'll just have to wait until the Vegas article to get back down into the twos (or maybe he'll surprise me). As always your comments are welcome.


Posted by Awful Announcing- at 1:52 PM

20 Comments:

I don't think Al Michaels would be one of the announcers. Simmons likes him. Is there anyone else with AM that it could be?

And I can't take seriously any list that doesn't include Billy Packer's stupid ass.

Chip Wesley said...
Aug 9, 2006, 3:45:00 PM  

I don't know about you AA, but i am very surprized he listed the announcers. I was shocked considering YWML, Deadhead, and Joe dumbass are ESPN employees. Oh well. Joe doesn't know how to use a computer anyway so I doubt it matters. I def think he is reading the blog though; hopefully it woke his ass up.

JPost said...
Aug 9, 2006, 3:46:00 PM  

Chip,
I was one of the guys who gave him the list and I looked all over the web for another AM and i really couldn't find one. The only one that made any sense was Michaels, even though I don't agree with it.

JPost said...
Aug 9, 2006, 3:52:00 PM  

here's the link I used from Wikipedia.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_sports_announcers

JPost said...
Aug 9, 2006, 3:55:00 PM  

I'm surprised as well, and I thought that he like Michaels as well. Here are some others it could be.

Al McGuire- very possible.
Ann Meyers- not likely.

AwfulAnnouncing said...
Aug 9, 2006, 4:02:00 PM  

I thought it was a very good article, but it has been a slow week at work.

Steve said...
Aug 9, 2006, 5:08:00 PM  

whoa... don't go trash talking Marquette's very own Al McGuire. He is second only to Wade as a god on campus... well, if he were alive.

I wouldn't think it would be Al Michaels either, but i guess it's possible.

Greg said...
Aug 9, 2006, 5:57:00 PM  

Everyon always rags on Bill Walton. I don't know why. Bill Walton and Marv Albert announce games in my wet dreams.

Tom said...
Aug 9, 2006, 9:52:00 PM  

Umm... guys?

I mentioned this one the other day in one of the comments section, and I sure read that setup as saying: This is what a reader sent me.

I could be wrong, but I still think he just re-printed an entire reader's email.

Alex said...
Aug 10, 2006, 7:17:00 AM  

Actually I think the reader email just had the first three rules/changes and SG added 30 more. At least that's how I read into it.

Chip Wesley said...
Aug 10, 2006, 11:06:00 AM  

The David Stern thing was an awesome idea. And I'd love to see the bullpen car more: I saw Jose Lima drive up in it once at the Hollywood Stars Game in Dodger Stadium, and it was great.

And I absolutely love Bill Walton. Especially when he talks about the Grateful Dead. Plus, I think his voice is kind of sexy but I am willing to admit that's probably just me.

Nyssa23 said...
Aug 10, 2006, 12:23:00 PM  

Umm yea Nyssa...I think you're alone in that regard.

AwfulAnnouncing said...
Aug 10, 2006, 3:21:00 PM  

A comment in bulleted form:

To me this was an ideal Simmons piece:
-fairly funny (for ESPN)
-light on Red Sox, Celtics content
-no in-depth analyzing (there’s a reason he’s on Page 2)
-light on early/mid 90’s pop culture references

Additional thoughts:
-I’m with Chip, you can’t have a list of awful announcers without Billy Packer.
-I like Walton, a lot. I used to hate Walton in the mid/late 90’s b/c he could never take Karl Malone’s penis out of his mouth for long enough to call a good game, but I’ve come around in recent years. He may say a lot of stupid shit, and god-help-you if his kid is playing in the game, but overall he wins on enthusiasm and goofiness. We need more burnt-out acidheads on the air - just like we should steer clear of anyone who went to Dead shows but never took any drugs there (Ann Coulter).
-I like the DH, unpopular as it may be. I would actually argue that the DH makes managing a game tougher, and it certainly makes it more enjoyable for the fans. I just don’t buy all those “more strategy” arguments against it, you can teach a 10-year-old the principle of a double switch in about 5 minutes.
-Men’s tennis isn’t popular in America because we haven’t had any really good American players in a while. Really, you have to go back to 2000 with Sampras to find an American as a legit threat at every tournament. Roddick has had his moments, but has always been overshadowed by Federer, and Agassi is utterly dislikeable, even though he isn’t as huge an asshole as he used to be. I guarantee that if Federer or Nadal were American, everyone here would care about tennis again.

the good doctor said...
Aug 10, 2006, 3:39:00 PM  

You know, I think I glanced at that thing five times without seeing those lines between item 3 and 4. Work sucks.

Alex said...
Aug 10, 2006, 5:54:00 PM  

you can teach a 10-year-old the principle of a double switch in about 5 minutes.

please look at any archive footage of mike hargrove managing seattle against an NL team this season. you will be disabused of that hypothesis... or hargrove really is dumber than a 10yo.

between billy packer & dick vitale, it's almost impossible to enjoy watching college basketball unless the sound is off. unfortunately, as a UNC alum, the games i want to watch most usually include one of those two.

this was a good article. while i don't agree with all of his ideas, disagreement alone isn't a bad thing. nothing he said was outlandishly stupid.

jason said...
Aug 11, 2006, 1:17:00 PM  

Simmons has been saying that stuff about Shanahan for years. I doubt he's taking it from you.

Rick said...
Aug 11, 2006, 2:29:00 PM  

You like Bill Walton?!? I don't think I can read this blog anymore! :D

twins15 said...
Aug 13, 2006, 3:56:00 AM  

I'm with you, Awful. Big Red is the man when it comes to NBA. Well, him and Marv Albert.

mr. irrelevant said...
Aug 14, 2006, 4:27:00 PM  

Keep up the good work audi shark body kits ontario canada

Anonymous said...
Feb 21, 2007, 8:06:00 PM  

That's a great story. Waiting for more. Aston martin auto dismantling fitness Headphone receiver wireless

Anonymous said...
Apr 26, 2007, 10:08:00 AM  

Post a Comment